“Fissure #1” By Tim Daniel & Patricio Delpeche Review

El Sueño, Texas was a single street town withering under the shadow of the Mexico—U.S. Barrier. Then the pavement split, and a massive crack spread from one end to the other, rapidly swallowing El Sueño whole. Young couple Avery Lee Olmos and Hark Wright fight to escape the mysterious sinkhole and the malevolent force that beckons from its depths.

This comic book presents an intriguing concept with elements of horror and social commentary, but ultimately falls short in execution. While the premise of this comic book promises an engaging narrative, the issue struggles with pacing and character development, leaving much to be desired.

The story in this comic book is set in a small Texas town where a mysterious fissure appears, threatening the community and unveiling underlying tensions. The creators of this comic book attempts to weave a narrative that blends supernatural elements with real-world issues, such as immigration and socio-political divides. Unfortunately, the execution lacks cohesion and depth, making it difficult for me personally to fully engage with the plot or its themes.

The character development in this comic book is one of the key areas where this comic book falters. The protagonists are introduced with potential for depth, but their personalities and motivations remain underdeveloped. This lack of depth makes it challenging for me personally to connect with them or invest in their journey. Without strong character arcs, the story struggles to maintain emotional resonance and impact.

The pacing of this comic book is pretty uneven, with certain scenes feeling rushed while others drag without significant progression. This inconsistency disrupts the narrative flow, making it difficult for me personally to stay engaged. A more balanced approach to pacing could have allowed for deeper exploration of both the characters and the story’s central conflict.

The artwork is a highlight in this comic book, because it is capturing the eerie and unsettling atmosphere of the narrative. The use of shadows and contrast enhances the sense of foreboding, effectively conveying the tension and mystery surrounding the fissure. However, while the art sets the mood, it occasionally lacks the dynamic quality needed to elevate the storytelling fully.

Despite its shortcomings this comic book does have moments that hint at its potential. The concept of a mysterious fissure exposing societal issues is intriguing, and with more focused storytelling, it could become a compelling narrative. However, the issue fails to capitalize on this potential, offering little more than a surface-level exploration of its themes.

I Give This Book 2 / 5

“Strawberry Love #001” By Irono Review

20-year-old university student, Sara Moritani, rushes back to the countryside to help her grandfather with his farm after he’s been injured. There, she meets a veteran strawberry farmer named Minori Sugiura, who is 13 years older than she is. He teaches Sara the ropes of strawberry farming. At first, she was frightened by Minori’s intimidating demeanor. But after discovering many surprising sides to him, she could feel love taking roots within her heart. On the other side of the relationship, Minori finds himself attracted to Sara. But due to their age difference, he finds it difficult to express his feelings to her… Thus begins a pure and touching love story between these two awkward lovebirds.

This comic book introduces us as readers to a world of romance and youthful exploration, but while it has moments of charm, it ultimately struggles to deliver a compelling narrative. But as always I will explain everything in this review, so if you are interested in hearing my thoughts about this comic book then keep reading this review my dear reader.

The story in this comic book centers around a young protagonist navigating the complexities of first love in a high school setting. This comic book tries to capture the emotions and challenges that accompany teenage romance, exploring themes of friendship, jealousy, and self-discovery.

While the premise holds promise, the plot is hampered by predictability and a lack of depth. The storyline follows a well-trodden path without offering fresh perspectives or unexpected twists, making it difficult to maintain engagement throughout the narrative.

The character development is one of the weaker aspects of this comic book. The protagonist, while relatable in their experiences, often feels one-dimensional. Their journey through love and self-discovery lacks the complexity and nuance needed to create a truly engaging character arc.

Supporting characters, including friends and romantic interests, are similarly underdeveloped. They often fall into stereotypical roles, serving more as plot devices than fully fleshed-out individuals. This lack of depth in character portrayal limits the emotional impact of the story and makes it challenging for me personally to connect with the characters on a meaningful level.

At the same time this comic book tries to explore themes of love, identity, and the challenges of growing up. However, these themes are not thoroughly examined, resulting in a superficial exploration that fails to resonate. The narrative touches on these ideas without delving deeply enough to provide substantial insight or emotional engagement.

The writing itself in this comic book is pretty straightforward but lacks the emotional depth and vividness that could elevate the story. Dialogue often feels stilted, and the prose is lacking in descriptive detail, which hampers my ability to fully immerse myself in the narrative of this comic book. The writing does not effectively convey the complexities of the characters’ emotions or the intricacies of their relationships.

The setting of this comic book is primarily a high school environment, a familiar backdrop for stories of teenage romance. However, the depiction of this setting is superficial, lacking the detail and authenticity needed to create a convincing and immersive backdrop.

The potential to explore the intricacies of high school life and its impact on personal identity is largely overlooked. The world-building is minimal, with little effort made to establish a vivid sense of place or atmosphere. This lack of immersive detail detracts from the overall reading experience, making the environments feel generic rather than integral to the story.

This comic book faces several significant challenges that hinder its success. The plot, while initially intriguing, quickly becomes predictable and lacks focus. The narrative relies on familiar tropes without adding significant innovation or depth, resulting in a story that feels formulaic and uninspired.

The character motivations and relationships we get in this comic book are poorly defined, making it difficult for me personally to empathize with their struggles and desires. The emotional connections between characters are not effectively portrayed, reducing the impact of key plot points and diminishing the overall emotional weight of the story.

Additionally, the pacing of this comic book is inconsistent, with key moments of tension and conflict either rushed or dragged out. This disrupts the narrative flow and diminishes the impact of pivotal scenes, which has left me personally feeling disconnected from the story.

I Give This Book 2 / 5

“My Favorite VTuber Is Scary IRL #001” By Riyo Yorima Review

Starting a new job at “Delivery Eats” has one BIG challenge–a scary-looking lady who’s a regular customer. She glares at you every time you deliver her food, and in this rural town, there’s only one delivery boy to handle her orders. But on his next visit, she finally speaks–and he recognizes her voice as none other than his favorite VTuber, Hanae Fuwari! Even more shocking, she offers to pay him just to chat with her?! This is the comedic tale of an introverted delivery boy and a shy but intimidating-looking woman getting a second chance at youth!

This comic book presents a unique premise that explores the intersection of digital personas and real-life identities. Despite its intriguing concept, this comic book struggles with execution but as always I will explain everything in this review. So if you are interested in hearing my thoughts about this comic book than by all means keep reading this review.

The story in this comic book follows the protagonist, a devoted fan of a popular VTuber, who is known for her charming online persona. Enthralled by her content, the protagonist eagerly anticipates meeting her in real life, only to discover that the VTuber’s actual personality is far more intimidating and complex than her digital façade suggests.

As the narrative unfolds in this comic book, the protagonist navigates the challenges of reconciling the idealized version of his favorite VTuber with her true self. This journey delves into themes of identity, perception, and the often-blurred line between online entertainment and reality.

Overall the plot in this comic book had the potential to be very good and interesting. But the way it is presented to us as readers, makes this comic book feel very flat and boring. The plot itself in this book feels pretty unrealistic and cringy, as it is the case with all manga comic books I have read in my time. I personally I’m not a fan of manga even thou I’m trying to get into manga but every manga comic book I read just shows me that maybe this category isn’t for me.

The character development is one of the weaker aspects of this comic book. The protagonist, while relatable in his fandom, lacks depth and growth. His journey from adoration to disillusionment is not sufficiently explored, leaving his character arc feeling incomplete and unconvincing.

The VTuber herself, a central figure in the story, is portrayed with intriguing contrasts. However, her character lacks the complexity needed to fully engage me personally. While the concept of her dual personas is interesting, it is not developed with the nuance necessary to create a compelling and believable character.

Supporting characters, who could provide additional layers to the narrative, are underutilized and serve mainly as plot devices. Their interactions with the protagonist and the VTuber are superficial, missing opportunities to deepen the story’s emotional impact and thematic exploration.

This comic book tries to explore themes of identity, authenticity, and the impact of digital personas on real-life interactions. While these themes are relevant and thought-provoking, their execution is uneven. The narrative touches on these ideas without delving deeply enough to offer substantial insight or resonance.

The writing itself in this comic book is pretty straightforward but lacks the emotional depth and vividness that could elevate the story. The dialogue often feels stilted, and the prose is lacking in descriptive detail, which hampers my ability to fully immerse myself in the narrative of this comic book. The writing does not effectively convey the complexities of the characters’ emotions or the intricacies of their relationships.

The setting of this comic book is primarily contemporary, with a focus on the world of online streaming and fandom. While the digital backdrop offers potential for exploration, the depiction of this environment is superficial and lacks authenticity. This comic book misses opportunities to explore the intricacies of the VTuber industry and its impact on both creators and fans.

The world-building is minimal in this comic book, with little effort made to establish a vivid sense of place or atmosphere. This lack of immersive detail detracts from the overall reading experience, making the environments feel generic rather than integral to the story.

The plot in this comic book while initially intriguing, quickly becomes predictable and lacks focus. The narrative relies on familiar tropes without adding significant innovation or depth, resulting in a story that feels formulaic and uninspired.

Character motivations and relationships are poorly defined, making it difficult for me personally to empathize with their struggles and desires. The emotional connections between characters are not effectively portrayed, reducing the impact of key plot points and diminishing the overall emotional weight of the story.

Additionally, the pacing of this comic book is pretty inconsistent, with key moments of tension and conflict either rushed or dragged out. This disrupts the narrative flow and diminishes the impact of pivotal scenes, which has left me personally feeling disconnected from the story.

I Give This Book 2 / 5

“Magic Whistle #0” By Sam Henderson Review

Enter the world of Sam Henderson’s Magic Whistle and it’s insane cast of characters. Collected for the first time here are the funniest comics from a decade of insanity. Learn new uses for your robot duck.

This comic book tries to deliver a blend of offbeat humor and absurdist sketches, but unfortunately, it struggles to resonate. At the same time this comic book aims to entertain with its unique style and wit, it falls short in execution and broader appeal.

Sam Henderson is known for his distinctive brand of humor, often characterized by surreal, nonsensical narratives and simple, cartoonish art. “Magic Whistle #0” stays true to this style, presenting a series of vignettes and gags intended to provoke laughter and surprise. However, the humor is hit-or-miss, with many jokes feeling flat or overly reliant on shock value.

The artwork itself in this comic book is deliberately simplistic, employing a minimalistic approach that aligns with the comedic style of this comic book. While this can be effective for visual gags and quick humor, it often lacks the detail and depth that might engage readers more fully. The art serves its purpose in delivering punchlines but doesn’t offer much beyond that in terms of visual appeal.

One of the main challenges of this comic book in my opinion is its inconsistency. Some segments deliver clever, witty humor that lands well, showcasing this comic book’s ability to craft amusing and unexpected scenarios. However, these moments are overshadowed by a larger number of sketches that feel underdeveloped or repetitive. The lack of a cohesive theme or narrative thread makes the comic feel more like a collection of random thoughts rather than a structured piece of work.

Another issue with this comic book is the niche nature of the humor. This comic book’s style is unique and may appeal to a specific audience that appreciates absurdity and irreverence. However, for readers unfamiliar with his work or those who prefer more traditional comedic structures, the content may come across as confusing or unengaging.

Despite its shortcomings, this comic book does have moments that hint at its potential. This comic book’s willingness to experiment with form and content is commendable, and his distinct voice is evident throughout. For fans of alternative comics and those who enjoy exploring the fringes of the genre, there may be elements of interest within these pages.

I Give This Book 2 / 5

“Fearless Dawn / Asylum Press Sampler: Free Comic Book 2013” By Frank Forte & Steve Mannion & Dwayne Harris Review

A great way to introduce Fearless Dawn and Asylum Press to retailers and fans. Featuring a sampling on new and upcoming comics. Fearless Outer Space features Steve Mannion’s bodacious bad girl is back in this superbly drawn comic book masterpiece! In this issue, Fearless Dawn’s arch nemesis Helga Von Krause is at it again, this time planning an attack from Outer Space. Of course, no one believes Fearless Dawn when she predicts the attack, so our gal has to do it all alone… again! Will Fearless Dawn save planet Earth? Retro-Rockets, Muscle-Bound Monsters, Babes and Machine-Guns litter the sequential landscape in this latest offering from The Maestro.

This comic book tries to showcase a variety of stories from Asylum Press, with contributions from creators like Frank Forte, Steve Mannion, and Dwayne Harris. Despite its potential, the sampler falls short in execution.

At the same time this comic book aims to introduces us as readers to the eclectic world of Asylum Press, featuring a mix of genres from horror to adventure. However, the overall experience is inconsistent, with some stories failing to leave a lasting impression. This comic book suffers from a lack of cohesion, making it feel more like a collection of disconnected pieces rather than a unified offering.

Steve Mannion’s “Fearless Dawn” segment attempts to capture a pulp-inspired adventure, filled with action and humor. While the artwork is energetic and Mannion’s style is distinctive, the narrative lacks depth and coherence. The story feels rushed, leaving little room for character development or plot progression. Despite its lively visuals, the segment doesn’t fully engage readers or make them invested in the outcome.

Frank Forte’s contributions lean towards horror and dark fantasy, showcasing a grittier side of Asylum Press. However, the storytelling often feels disjointed, with abrupt transitions and underdeveloped plots. Forte’s art style, while atmospheric, is not enough to overcome the narrative shortcomings. The stories lack the suspense and tension needed to captivate fans of the horror genre.

Dwayne Harris’s work adds a sci-fi element to the sampler, but similar issues persist. The narrative is intriguing in concept but suffers from limited execution within the confines of the sampler format. The artwork is detailed and visually engaging, yet the story doesn’t deliver enough context or development to fully draw readers in.

One of the main challenges of this comic book in my opinion is its inability to provide a satisfying introduction to the worlds it presents. The brevity of each segment leaves many narrative threads unexplored, resulting in a fragmented reading experience. This lack of depth and continuity makes it difficult for me personally to connect with the stories or become invested in the characters.

Despite these issues, this comic book does have moments that hint at the potential of Asylum Press’s offerings. The diversity of genres and artistic styles suggests a creative and varied lineup. However, the execution in this particular comic book does not do justice to the possibilities inherent in its premise.

I Give This Book 2 / 5

“Scott Pilgrim Vol. 3 (of 6): Scott Pilgrim and the Infinite Sadness – Color Edition Preview (Scott Pilgrim)” By Bryan Lee O’Malley Review

This comic book offers a colorful reimagining of the beloved series. However, despite the vibrant presentation, this preview falls short of capturing the full charm of the original.

The story in this comic book continues Scott Pilgrim’s journey as he navigates the challenges of love and rivalry, focusing on his battle against the third of Ramona’s evil exes. While the premise remains engaging, this comic book struggles to deliver the depth and humor that fans have come to expect from the series.

The pacing of this comic book is pretty uneven. Key plot points are touched upon but not fully developed, leaving the story feeling rushed and disjointed. This lack of cohesion makes it difficult for me personally to become truly invested in the unfolding events or to appreciate the stakes of Scott’s ongoing battles. The comedic timing, which is crucial to Scott Pilgrim’s appeal, seems off, resulting in humor that falls flat.

The character development in this comic book is pretty lacking. Scott’s charm and quirks, while present, are not explored in depth, making his journey feel superficial. Ramona and the other supporting characters also suffer from a lack of depth, reducing them to mere placeholders rather than fully realized individuals.

The dialogues in this comic book feels less impactful in this comic book than in the other comic books in this Eries. The witty exchanges and pop-culture references that typically enrich the narrative are sparse, which has left me personally craving the cleverness and relatability that define the series.

I Give This Book 2 / 5

“Mega-Kid: Ready for Action!” By Nigel Johnson & Damion Johnson Review

Dive into a thrilling tale where four imaginative friends create the ultimate superhero, Mega-Kid! In a world buzzing with tech and screen time, these brave kids harness the power of their creativity to save their town’s cherished park.

This comic book introduces us as readers to a young superhero’s adventures, aiming to capture the excitement and wonder of youthful heroism. Unfortunately, despite a promising concept, the execution falls short.

The premise behind his comic book centers around Mega-Kid, a typical young hero with extraordinary abilities, tasked with saving the day. While the idea of a kid superhero is appealing and offers potential for engaging storytelling, the narrative struggles to find its footing. The plot is predictable and lacks depth, following a formulaic approach that doesn’t offer much in the way of surprises or innovation.

One of the main issues I had with this comic book is its pacing. The narrative moves too quickly, rushing through key moments without allowing for proper development or emotional resonance. This hurried approach makes it difficult for me personally to become fully invested in the characters or their journey. Important plot points are glossed over, leaving the story feeling shallow and incomplete.

The character development in this comic book is another area where this comic book falters in my opinion. Kid, despite being the protagonist, is not given enough depth or complexity to stand out. His motivations and personality are only superficially explored, making it hard for me personally to connect with or root for him. Supporting characters fare no better, often serving as mere plot devices rather than fully realized individuals.

The dialogues throughout this comic book are often stilted and clichéd, lacking the natural flow needed to bring the characters and their interactions to life. This comic book is compounded by the lack of humor or wit that could have added charm and personality to the story.

The artwork itself in this comic book is serviceable but lacks the dynamism and detail needed to elevate the narrative. The illustrations are simple and straightforward, which suits the story’s tone but fails to capture the excitement and action one might expect from a superhero tale.

Despite these shortcomings, this comic book does have moments that hint at its potential. The concept of a young superhero navigating challenges and discovering their abilities is appealing and could resonate with younger audiences. However, the execution needs refinement to fully realize this potential.

I Give This Book 2 / 5

“FCBD: Our Favorite Thing is My Favorite Thing is Monsters” By Emil Ferris Review

Emil Ferris’s runaway smash hit My Favorite Thing Is Monsters has been the graphic novel event of the decade and for this year’s Free Comic Book Day, Ferris has delivered something truly an all-new, 16-page Monsters story exclusive to FCBD readers. Additionally, Our Favorite Thing Is My Favorite Thing Is Monsters features two other Ferris short stories never before a six-page autobiographical story about the harrowing circumstances that led to the creation of My Favorite Thing Is Monsters, as well as a five-page “how to” strip appropriately titled, “How To Draw a Monster”!

This comic book tries to offer us as readers a taste of her acclaimed graphic novel. However, this free comic book day edition struggles to capture the depth and intricacy of the original work.

The original graphic novel is celebrated for its unique art style and complex narrative, blending elements of horror, mystery, and coming-of-age themes. Unfortunately, this comic book fails to encapsulate the richness of Ferris’s vision. The excerpt feels more like a fragmented snapshot than a cohesive introduction, which can be confusing for me personally unfamiliar with the full story.

The artwork itself in this comic book remains distinctive. The detailed, cross-hatched illustrations are reminiscent of classic horror comics, with a sketchbook aesthetic that is both raw and captivating. However, the lack of context in this edition makes it difficult for the art to shine as it does in the complete work. Without the broader narrative to support it, the art feels disconnected from any meaningful storyline.

The narrative in this comic book suffers from a lack of clarity. The selected scenes jump abruptly, providing little in the way of exposition or character development. We as readers are introduced to the protagonist, Karen Reyes, but her motivations and the world she inhabits are not sufficiently explored. This lack of depth makes it challenging for new readers to connect with the characters or understand the significance of the events depicted.

The dialogues and storytelling aspect of this comic book are often cryptic, hinting at deeper themes without providing adequate exploration. This comic book’s strength lies in her ability to weave complex narratives, but the brevity of this FCBD edition undermines that strength. The themes of identity, monstrosity, and societal norms are touched upon but not developed, which has left me personally with more questions than answers.

This comic book does succeed in showcasing this comic book’s artistic talent and her unique approach to storytelling. It hints at the potential depth and complexity of the full graphic novel, which has intrigued me personally to continue reading this comic book series. However, as a standalone piece, it lacks the coherence and engagement needed to make it a satisfying read.

I Give This Book 2 / 5

“The Everlasting Return” By L.E. Mullin Review

Sheena McNeil, Sequential Tart.Eight-year-old Jack West never imagined that his grandfather’s books, filled with tales of the terrifying villain mR mILDEW, could be anything but harmless stories.But one night, he catches a glimpse of his new neighbor, dressed as the malevolent character, and realizes that the horror is all too real. As he uncovers the truth about his grandfather’s disappearance, Jack finds himself drawn into a world of dark magic, twisted fantasy, and apocalyptic danger. With the fate of the world hanging in the balance, can Jack summon the courage to face mR mILDEW and his sinister powers?

This comic book tries to weave a tale of mystery and fantasy, but despite an intriguing premise, it struggles to deliver a cohesive and engaging story. While the book has moments of potential but it struggles with execution issues.

This comic book introduces us as readers to a world where time and reality are fluid, exploring themes of destiny and rebirth. The concept itself is intriguing, hinting at deep philosophical questions and the potential for complex character development. However, the narrative’s execution falls short, leaving many of these themes underexplored.

One of the main issues I had with this comic book is the pacing. The story often feels disjointed, with scenes that jump abruptly from one to another without sufficient transition or development. This lack of narrative flow makes it difficult for me personally to fully immerse myself in the world or connect with the characters. Key moments that should evoke emotion or tension often feel rushed, undermining their impact.

The character development is another area where this comic book falters in my opinion. While the protagonist is introduced with a compelling backstory, their journey lacks depth and growth. Supporting characters are similarly underdeveloped, often appearing as mere plot devices rather than fully realized individuals. This lack of character depth makes it challenging for me personally to invest in their journeys or care about their outcomes.

The writing in this comic book is a mixed bag in this comic book. There are passages where Mullin’s prose shines, offering vivid descriptions and evocative imagery. However, these moments are overshadowed by sections of awkward dialogue and exposition-heavy narration. The dialogue often feels stilted and unnatural, failing to capture the nuances of real conversation. Additionally, the reliance on exposition can make the story feel more like a lecture than an engaging narrative.

Despite these shortcomings, this comic book does have its strengths. The world-building, while not fully realized, offers glimpses of creativity and imagination. Certain scenes hint at a larger, intriguing universe that could have been more thoroughly explored. These elements suggest that with more development, the story could have achieved greater depth and resonance.

I Give This Book 2 / 5

“Free Comic Book Day 2017 – BOOM! Summer Blast” By David Petersen & Sam Sykes & Liz Prince Review

BOOM! Studios Summer Blast is jam-packed with three stories of mice, monsters, and one supernatural punk band. In an original Archaia short story of David Petersen’s Mouse Guard, a pair of youngfurs learn a lesson from a grizzled guardmouse on the value of looking out for one another. Next, get a sneak peek of the upcoming KaBOOM! series Brave Chef Brianna. To prove herself as a great chef, Brianna starts her own restaurant…but the only town she can afford to set up shop in is Monster City! Finally, the Lumberjanes introduce your new favorite BOOM! Box series Coady and the Creepies. Coady and her sisters are members of a band heading for the gig of their lives…so long as no one realizes that Coady is actually a ghost!

This comic book brings together the talents of creators like David Petersen, Sam Sykes, and Liz Prince, aiming to offer a comic book with diverse storytelling available from BOOM! Studios.

The anthology format in this comic book presents several short stories, each showcasing different styles and genres. While this variety is meant to appeal to a wide audience, it also results in an uneven experience. Some stories manage to capture interest, while others feel rushed or underdeveloped, which has left me personally with a sense of incompleteness.

David Petersen’s contribution is visually engaging, with his signature detailed artwork bringing a level of craftsmanship that stands out. His story, however, lacks depth and feels more like a teaser than a complete narrative. While the artwork is captivating, the plot doesn’t provide enough substance to leave a lasting impression.

This comic book offers a story that attempts to blend humor and fantasy. The premise is intriguing, but the execution feels hurried, with characters that don’t have enough room to develop. The dialogue aims for wit but often falls flat, lacking the punch needed to make the humor land effectively. This leaves the story feeling more like a missed opportunity than a memorable entry.

Liz Prince’s contribution leans towards slice-of-life storytelling, offering a more grounded narrative. While it provides a change of pace, the story is too brief to fully engage me personally. The characters are relatable, but the narrative lacks the depth and emotional resonance needed to make it stand out in an anthology format.

This comic book’s biggest challenge is its lack of cohesion. The stories, while diverse, don’t connect thematically or tonally, making the overall reading experience disjointed. This lack of unity might leave readers feeling disconnected, unable to find a consistent thread to follow throughout the issue.

Additionally, the pacing is an issue across the board in this comic book. Each story seems to rush towards its conclusion, not allowing for proper development or build-up. This hurried approach undermines the potential impact of each narrative, making them feel forgettable.

While this comic book is designed to showcase the range of BOOM! Studios’ offerings, it doesn’t quite succeed in making a strong case for its lineup. This comic book serves more as a brief introduction than a compelling invitation to explore further. For new readers, it may not provide the engaging entry point intended.

I Give This Book 2 / 5