Tag: 2 Star Reviews

Meet Chise, a young girl who is reborn in a new world with her old memories lost. A goddess grants her the gift of ‘Creation Magic’ under one condition – that she enjoys her new life! Together with Teto, a golem she creates, Chise embarks on an enchanting journey across the world.

This comic book presents an intriguing premise but struggles with execution. At the same time this comic book combines elements of fantasy and slice-of-life, offering potential that is not fully realized.

The story in this comic book follows a witch who discovers a loophole allowing her to access infinite magical power. This concept is promising, opening the door to creative storytelling and humorous scenarios. However, the narrative lacks depth and focus, often relying on repetitive plot points that fail to engage me personally fully.

The character development is one of this comic book’s significant weaknesses. The protagonist, while initially interesting, lacks depth and complexity. Her motivations and personality are underexplored, making it difficult for readers to connect with her journey. The supporting characters, introduced with little backstory or development, serve primarily as foils or comedic relief, rather than adding meaningful layers to the narrative.

The writing style in this comic book introduces a world filled with magical possibilities, but the execution is uneven. The dialogue often feels forced and lacks the wit and charm needed to elevate the story. Conversations serve more as exposition than genuine interactions, which detracts from the potential for dynamic character exchanges.

The artwork is a redeeming aspect of this comic book. The illustrations capture the whimsical nature of the magical world with vibrant designs and expressive characters. The visual style adds an element of charm, enhancing the lighthearted tone of the story. However, even strong artwork cannot fully compensate for the narrative shortcomings.

The pacing of this comic book is very inconsistent, with scenes that either drag without adding value or rush through potentially significant moments. This inconsistency disrupts the flow of the story, making it challenging for me personally to maintain interest or fully grasp the plot’s progression.

Despite its weaknesses, this comic book’s concept holds potential for future development. With a stronger narrative structure and deeper exploration of character motivations, subsequent installments could better capture the whimsy and creativity inherent in the premise.

I Give This Book 2 / 5

A young woman loses her memories, and her fiancé insists that she was head over heels for him before the accident…but they’re both lying!Viola, the daughter of a viscount, is engaged to Philip Laurenson, the charming and popular heir to a duke. But the two are far from a match, and their silent tea parties do little to help them bond. In a desperate bid to escape the engagement, Viola feigns amnesia after a minor accident. However, Philip’s reaction is not at all what she expected, as he starts telling her how much they used to love each other and how she used to call him…”Phil”? Which is far from the truth! And yet, from the brink of a crumbling engagement, a romance begins to blossom between the inexperienced lord and the oblivious lady.

This comic book offers an intriguing premise but struggles with execution, at the same time this comic book tries to blend romance and comedy, yet it falls short in delivering a cohesive and engaging narrative.

The story in this comic book centers around a protagonist who fakes amnesia to escape an engagement, only to find her fiancé more affectionate than ever. While the setup promises humor and romantic tension, the plot quickly becomes predictable. The initial intrigue of the amnesia ruse fades as the story leans heavily on clichés without offering fresh twists or deeper insights into the characters’ motivations.

The character development in this comic book is a significant area of concern. The protagonist’s motivations are not fully explored, making her actions feel superficial. Her internal conflicts and emotions are underdeveloped, which detracts from the potential complexity of her situation. Similarly, the fiancé’s sudden shift to being “lovey-dovey” lacks depth, reducing him to a one-dimensional figure rather than a nuanced character.

The side characters in this comic book arent any better. They often serving as mere plot devices without substantial backstory or individuality. Their interactions with the main characters lack the emotional weight necessary to create meaningful connections or drive the narrative forward.

The writing style in this comic book is pretty straightforward, but it often lacks the wit and charm needed to elevate the comedic elements of the story. The dialogue tends to be repetitive, missing opportunities for clever banter or insightful exchanges that could enhance character development and engagement.

The artwork in this comic book, while visually appealing, cannot fully compensate for the narrative shortcomings. The illustrations capture the characters’ expressions and settings effectively, adding a layer of visual interest to the story. However, the art alone cannot elevate the overall reading experience when the plot and character development are lacking.

At the same time the pacing in this comic book is very uneven. There are some scenes dragging while others rush through potentially significant moments. This inconsistency disrupts the flow of the story, making it challenging to maintain interest or emotional investment in the characters’ journeys.

I Give This Book 2 / 5

Alto, an aspiring magician, is on the verge of repeating a grade when he stumbles upon a mysterious book containing a demon powerful enough to bring about the end of the world—the alluring Vermeil. But Vermeil’s demonic powers are nothing compared to her naughty and mischievous antics! Action, drama, and magical challenges await them, and it all begins with their fateful encounter.

I gotta admit here that this comic book had an intriguing premise but in the end it does struggles with execution. At the same time this comic book had a lot of potential which it didn’t use.

This comic book sets the stage for a magical adventure that doesn’t quite reach its potential as I have said above. 

The story in this comic book follows Alto, a struggling student at a magical academy, who accidentally summons Vermeil, a powerful and enigmatic being.

The setup of the story in this comic book promises a blend of fantasy and humor, exploring themes of growth and unexpected alliances. The dynamic between Alto and Vermeil is central to the narrative, providing opportunities for both comedic and dramatic moments.

The story in this comic book often rushes through key events, sacrificing character development and world-building for the sake of plot progression. This have caused me to have a disjointed reading experience, where the stakes feel less significant and the emotional impact is diminished.

The writing style in this comic book introduces a world filled with magical elements and potential for character development. However, the execution feels rushed, with the plot moving quickly without fully establishing the setting or the rules of the magical world. This lack of depth have left me personally confused and less invested in the story as I wanted to be.

The character development in this comic book is another area where the volume falls short. Alto, as the protagonist, is portrayed as a typical underdog, but the narrative doesn’t delve deeply into his motivations or personal struggles. Vermeil, while intriguing as a character, is not given enough backstory or complexity to fully engage me personally. 

The interactions in this comic book between the two main characters, though occasionally amusing, lack the depth needed to make their relationship compelling.

When it comes to the side characters in this comic book are introduced with minimal context, often serving as stereotypical figures rather than fully fleshed-out individuals. This limits their impact on the story and reduces opportunities for richer character interactions and development.

The artwork in this comic book is a redeeming quality of the volume. The illustrations capture the magical and fantastical elements of the story, with detailed character designs and dynamic action scenes. The visual style adds energy to the narrative and helps convey the whimsical aspects of the magical world.

I Give This Book 2 / 5

Introduction for Valiant Shadowman Vol. 1! Collecting Shadowman’s legendary first appearance in the original Valiant Universe – featuring classic work by Steve Ditko, Steve Englehart, Bob Hall, David Lapham, Jim Shooter and more! Jack Boniface nearly died one night – attacked by something out of a nightmare. But since that terrifying experience something has changed. Now, when darkness falls, a feeling comes over him, an urge to destroy the demons that would defile the New Orleans night. Wild, reckless, and hell-bent on eliminating evil in all its forms, Jack is now his city’s new protector – the nocturnal avenger simply called Shadowman. This Valiant Masters volume collects SHADOWMAN (1992) #0-7 and material from DARQUE PASSAGES (1994) #1.

Let me start this review by saying that this one is just a preview for the entire comic book. And I read it because I wanted to see if the full comic book was worth the money and time I would spend on it. And I’m gonna give you the answer for that at the end of this review.

This premise of this preview revolves around Jack Boniface, the Shadowman, a character who has long been a staple in the Valiant Universe. Set against the backdrop of New Orleans, the setting offers a rich tapestry of culture and mysticism. However, despite this potential, the narrative fails to fully utilize the vibrant and atmospheric setting, resulting in a story that feels generic rather than immersive.

One of the main issues I had with this preview is the character development. The main character in this preview has some complex history and deep emotional layers. But this preview is sho watered down to such an extend that the main character is very shallow and have almost nonexistent personality.

The protagonist in this preview feels more like a caricature than a fully realized individual. This lack of depth makes it difficult to engage with or empathize with the character, which is crucial for a series centered on personal transformation and heroism.

The side characters in this preview also suffer from a lack of development. Many are introduced without sufficient backstory or context, making their presence feel more like filler than integral parts of the story. Their interactions with the main character of this preview are often superficial, lacking the emotional weight needed to drive the narrative forward.

The plot-wise aspect of this preview leans heavily on clichés and predictable twists. While there are moments of intrigue, they are overshadowed by a reliance on standard superhero tropes. The storyline lacks the originality or creativity needed to distinguish it from other entries in the genre, resulting in a narrative that feels stale rather than exciting.

The pacing of this preview is very uneven with certain sections dragging while others feel rushed. Key plot points are often glossed over which have left me with a sense of incompleteness and like the creators of this preview had no idea what they were doing with this one. This inconsistency disrupts the flow of the story, making it difficult to maintain interest.

On the positive side of this preview, the artwork does provide some redeeming qualities. The illustrations capture the dark and mystical tone that Shadowman embodies, with a visual style that complements the supernatural elements of the story. However, even strong artwork cannot fully compensate for the shortcomings in narrative and character development.

So will I buy and read the full version of this comic book ? I don’t think I will. The main reason behind this is how poorly this preview was very uninteresting for me personally.

I Give This Book 2 / 5

Three spooky stories to enjoy for Halloween.

I gotta admit here that this comic book had a lot of potential but in the end this comic book didnt use the potential that it had. But of course I will explain everything in this review, so if you are interested in hearing my thoughts on this comic book then keep reading.

This comic book tries to to capture the eerie essence of Halloween with a collection of short tales, the execution leaves much to be desired in the way the creator of this comic book presents those short stories to us in this comic book.

This comic book aims to deliver a series of chilling tales perfect for the Halloween season, each intending to evoke a sense of suspense and fright. However, the stories often lack the depth and creativity needed to truly captivate or unsettle me personally.

The plots in those short stories this comic book has are generally predictable, relying heavily on well-worn horror tropes without offering fresh twists or perspectives.

The character development aspect of this comic book is one of the weak points. The protagonists and supporting characters are often one-dimensional, with little background or motivation provided to make them relatable or engaging. This lack of depth makes it difficult for readers to become invested in their fates, which is crucial for any horror story aiming to create tension and emotional impact.

The atmospheric potential of Halloween-themed stories is immense, yet “Spooky Stories” struggles to fully utilize this. While some tales manage to create a faintly eerie ambiance, many fail to maintain it throughout. Descriptions of settings and scenarios are often superficial, lacking the vivid detail necessary to immerse people like me in the spooky world that the title promises.

This comic book has an huge issue with the pacing of the short stories that this comic book has. Several stories rush through key moments, disrupting the buildup of suspense and rendering climaxes less impactful. Conversely, some tales drag with unnecessary exposition, diminishing the overall tension and excitement. This inconsistency in pacing affects the anthology’s ability to maintain a steady level of engagement.

The one thing that I really liked in this comic book is the writing style which made me give this comic book 2 stars instead of 1 star. The writing style of this comic book is accessible and straightforward, making the collection an easy read. There are occasional glimpses of creativity in certain story concepts, suggesting potential that is not fully realized in this volume. These moments hint at what could have been a more successful anthology with greater development and polish.

I Give This Book 2 / 5

Asagaki Togo was the Red Ranger in a heroic Ranger squad. During their final battle against the ultimate evil organization, he suffers a crushing defeat and resigns himself to death… That is, until he finds himself reborn in an entirely different world! Embracing his new role as an adventurer, he transforms into Kizuna Red and continues his pursuit of justice, helping those in need. Enjoy this heroic tale of a Ranger becoming the protector of another world!

This comic book presents to us an pretty intriguing premise but struggles to deliver a compelling story. Because in a way the concept for this comic book is promising, the way it is executed and presented to us falls short in several key areas.

The narrative of this comic book follows the Red Ranger, a character transported from a familiar world of heroics into a fantasy realm filled with magic and monsters. This setup has the potential for exciting cross-genre storytelling, combining elements of superhero action with fantasy adventure. However this comic book fails to capitalize and deliver on this potential, resulting in a story that feels disjointed and underdeveloped.

One of the main issues I had with this comic book is it’s lack of character depth. The protagonist, despite being a recognizable hero, comes across as one-dimensional. His transition from a world of structured heroism to the unpredictability of a fantasy setting should be rife with internal conflict and growth, but this comic book instead offers a superficial portrayal of his journey. The lack of character development makes it difficult for readers to connect with or invest in his adventure.

The side characters in this comic book aren’t much better than the main character of this comic book. The side characters which are introduced alongside the Red Ranger often feel like placeholders rather than fully realized individuals. Their interactions with the protagonist lack substance, reducing them to mere plot devices rather than contributing meaningfully to the story. This lack of depth hampers the narrative, leaving it feeling hollow.

The plot in this comic book is another area which I wasn’t a fan of. Since the initial concept of the plot is pretty intriguing, the story quickly becomes bogged down by clichéd scenarios and predictable outcomes. The narrative leans heavily on well-worn tropes of both the isekai and superhero genres without offering any fresh twists or insights. This reliance on familiar plot devices results in a story that feels more like a rehash than an innovative blend of genres.

The pacing in this comic book is very uneven in this comic book. Because it has abrupt transitions and a lack of cohesive flow. Key events often feel rushed, with little buildup or payoff, while other sections drag with unnecessary exposition. This inconsistency disrupts the reading experience, making it challenging to maintain engagement.

However the only good thing about this comic book is the writing style in this comic book which is the best thing about this comic book. The writing style is accessible, and there are moments where the world-building shows glimpses of creativity. The fantasy realm is populated with intriguing creatures and magical elements that hint at untapped potential. Unfortunately, these moments are rare and not enough to elevate the overall narrative.

I Give This Book 2 / 5

The world is on the brink of extinction due to an ever-expanding disaster called the “Eternal Storm.” However, humanity has a new source of hope in this dying weapons which grant power beyond human understanding—the Ability Armaments. Two boys destined to inspire awe with their splendor set out on a journey. Ability Armaments in hand, they won’t stop until the world is saved!

This comic book gives us glimpses of an intriguing setup and a few sparks of momentum but the way this comic book is executed and presented to us makes this comic book feel like one of many shitty comic book I have read this year. 

This comic book have some good moments throughout. I mostly preferred the moments where the narrative had focused on the straightforward clash which made the comic book pretty interesting. 

At the same time this comic book gives us multiple teasers about rival factions and rules of engagement suggest a framework that could support richer stakes later on which would have been more enjoyable and interesting than this comic book.

In my opinion the characters in this comic book are very flat and shallow. The protagonists and rivals of this comic book feel like archetypes sketched in broad strokes, with motivations that read more like genre defaults than lived-in drives.

The characters in this comic book have also very minimal personalties to them which makes it pretty hard to tell them apart for me personally. 

This comic book has a very uneven pacing. There are long stretches of setup stall the story, then big moments arrive rushed, without the buildup needed to make them land.

The conflicts which are presented to us in this comic book resolve predictably, and the story rarely surprises which are either in plot turns or in how scenes are staged.

For the most part this comic book feels pretty repetitive. Because the training, posturing, and exposition cycles recur without adding new layers, making the middle third feel longer than it is.

I Give This Book 2 / 5

In the very near future, supernatural beings live among humans in peace, yet Jack Crimson finds his life as a werewolf frustrating, and wants nothing more than a cure. Desperate to free himself from this curse, he makes a series of decisions leading him down an unexpected path. Join Jack as he makes his way through this dark new world.

Let me start this review by saying that this one is just a preview for the entire comic book. And I read it because I wanted to see if the full comic book was worth the money and time I would spend on it. And I’m gonna give you the answer for that at the end of this review.

This preview attempts to introduce a dark, gritty world filled with intrigue and action, but ultimately falls short due to weak storytelling, underdeveloped characters, and uninspired art.

To be very honest here I gotta say that this preview feels like a very rough draft rather than a polished preview for the full version of this comic book.

The artwork in this preview is very fun and cute. Because it has a moody, gritty tone that fits the series’ theme, with some interesting character designs.

At the same time this preview has a a good potential which the creators of this preview didn’t use fully. I find the idea of a secretive society with dark motives to be very interesting but the way it is presented to us makes me feel like the potential of this preview wasn’t fully used.

The plot in this preview is confusing and poorly structured, with abrupt scene changes and little context to understand the characters’ motivations or the world.

The characters in this preview lack depth, development, or clear personalities, making it hard to care about their fates.

The artwork in this preview is functional but uninspired, with bland panels and a lack of visual dynamism that could have heightened the story.

This preview has also a lot of pacing issues. Because the story in this preview drags in places and feels rushed in others, leading to a disjointed reading experience.

So will I buy and read the full version of this comic book ? I don’t think I will. The main reason behind this is how poorly this preview was very uninteresting for me personally.

I Give This Book 2 / 5