“Shekhar Kapur’s Devi – Free Sampler” By Shekhar Kapur & Siddharth Kotian & Mukesh Singh Review

Dive into the world of Devi with this free sampler comic! Created by acclaimed filmmaker Shekhar Kapur (Elizabeth, Four Feathers, Bandit Queen). Tara Mehta, an unsuspecting young woman in the futuristic Asian city, Sitapur is the Devi. She has no idea that she is about to become the centerpiece of a divine battle between the Gods of Light and the demon Lord Bala. Devi is a powerhouse of a story about a young woman battling for survival in a landscape of ancient legends, duty and fate. She walks the line between tradition, destiny and free will. Where will she fall? Between the Divine and the Diabolical there is Devi.

This comic book offers us as readers a glimpse into an ambitious comic project that aims to blend mythology, modern storytelling, and striking visuals. Created by Shekhar Kapur, Siddharth Kotian, and Mukesh Singh, this comic book provides an intriguing preview of what promises to be a compelling series. However, as an introductory piece, it only partially delivers.

Visually, this comic book makes a strong impression. Mukesh Singh’s artwork is detailed and vibrant, capturing both the grandeur of divine figures and the gritty intensity of modern scenes. The artwork strives to evoke a sense of mythic grandeur while maintaining a contemporary edge, which is commendable.

The story in this comic book centers on Devi, a mythic goddess reimagined for the modern world, navigating complex moral and spiritual dilemmas. Kapur’s vision seems to be to create a mythology that resonates with today’s audience, blending traditional divine themes with contemporary comic book. The narrative, as presented in the sampler, is ambitious—introducing Devi as a powerful, conflicted character who must confront both divine and human challenges. The writing by Siddharth Kotian attempts to blend mythic grandeur with relatable emotional depth, but as a sampler, it often feels somewhat incomplete, leaving many questions unanswered.

One of the strengths of this comic book is its thematic ambition. It aims to explore themes of power, faith, and identity, which are very relevant in today’s context. The dialogue and narration hint at deeper conflicts and philosophical questions, but the limited scope of this comic book doesn’t allow for full development. Consequently, the story feels somewhat fragmented (promising, but not fully realized.) It’s clear that the creators want to craft something meaningful, but the sampler only scratches the surface.

The pacing of this comic book is brisk, which is understandable given the format, but this leaves little room for character development or emotional resonance. I personally found myself intrigued by Devi’s potential as a complex protagonist, but they don’t get enough context or background to feel deeply connected. As a result, this comic book serves more as a teaser than a fully fleshed-out story.

I Give This Book 3 / 5

“Preacher #1 AMC Edition” By Garth Ennis & Steve Dillon Review

Jesse Custer is a small-town preacher losing his faith—until he merges with a divine being called Genesis. Now he has firsthand knowledge of both Heaven and Hell and a voice that’s automatically obeyed by anyone. Joined by an Irish vampire and an ex-lover, Jesse sets out on a mission to find God.

This comic book is a compelling and provocative start to a series that has become legendary in the world of comic books. With its gritty storytelling, dark humor, and complex characters. At the same time this comic book is a highly engaging read that leaves a lasting impression, though not without some flaws.

This comic book features a reprint of the first issue, offering fans and newcomers alike a chance to experience the story in a crisp, new format. From the very first page, the art by Steve Dillon is striking (rough, detailed, and expressive)  perfectly capturing the gritty tone of the narrative. Dillon’s distinctive style lends an almost raw authenticity to the story’s dark themes, with characters that feel both intimidating and deeply human.

At its core, this comic book introduces us to Jesse Custer, a conflicted preacher in a small Texas town who becomes entwined in a supernatural plot after an encounter with a mysterious entity called Genesis. The writing in this comic book is sharp, gritty, and unapologetic, blending dark humor with brutal realism. The dialogue crackles with authenticity, and the characters are flawed and multi-dimensional, making them fascinating to follow. Jesse’s internal struggle (torn between his faith, his past, and the chaos unleashed by Genesis) sets the stage for a series that explores themes of morality, power, and redemption.

The story in this comic book kicks off with a shocking and memorable scene that sets the tone for what’s to come: a mix of violence, religious satire, and existential questioning. Ennis doesn’t shy away from controversial subjects, and his portrayal of religion is both critical and thought-provoking. This bold approach can be polarizing, but it’s also part of what makes “Preacher” so compelling (its willingness to confront uncomfortable truths head-on).

While there narrative in this comic book is gripping, some readers might find the pacing a little uneven. The first issue packs a lot of setup (introducing the main characters, the supernatural element, and the tone) sometimes at the expense of deeper emotional investment. However, this is understandable for this comic book of such an ambitious series. It leaves enough intrigue to keep me personally hooked and eager to see where the story will go next.

This comic book enhances the experience with clean, high-quality printing and restored artwork, making it a visually satisfying package. However, as a reprint, it doesn’t add new material, so fans already familiar with the series might find it more of a collector’s item than a must-read, while newcomers will find it a great entry point.

I Give This Book 4 / 5

“Monstress #1” By Marjorie M. Liu & Sana Takeda & Rus Wooton Review

Astonishing X-Men and Black Widow writer MARJORIE LIU returns to comics with artist SANA TAKEDA (X-23) for an all-new ONGOING SERIES! Steampunk meets Kaiju in this original fantasy epic for mature readers, as young Maika risks everything to control her psychic link with a monster of tremendous power, placing her in the center of a devastating war between human and otherworldly forces. The adventure begins in a spectacular TRIPLE-SIZED FIRST ISSUE, with SIXTY-SIX pages of story and no ads.

This comic book is an exceptional debut that immediately establishes itself as a standout in the realm of dark fantasy comics. From its stunning artwork to its intricate storytelling, this comic book promises a richly layered narrative that hooks the reader from the very first page.

The visual aesthetic of this comic book is nothing short of breathtaking. Sana Takeda’s artwork is a masterclass in detail and mood-setting. Her intricate linework, combined with a atmospheric world teeming with life and danger. Each panel is packed with textures and subtle details that reward close inspection, immersing the reader fully into this fantastical universe. Rus Wooton’s lettering complements Takeda’s art perfectly, ensuring that dialogue and narration flow seamlessly without detracting from the visual storytelling.

At its core, this comic book is a dark fantasy epic set in a war-torn world inspired by Asian mythology and folklore. The story introduces Maika Halfwolf, a young woman haunted by her past and a mysterious, monstrous power residing within her. From the outset, Maika’s character is compelling (vulnerable yet fierce, complex yet relatable.) The narrative deftly explores themes of trauma, identity, and survival, making her journey resonate on a deeply emotional level.

The plot in this comic book kicks off with a tense confrontation that quickly reveals a world teeming with political intrigue, ancient magic, and monstrous creatures. The writing in this comic book is sharp and evocative, establishing a tone that is both gritty and poetic. The world-building is meticulous but never overwhelming; it provides enough context for newcomers while hinting at a larger, more intricate universe that promises to unfold over subsequent issues. The pacing is brisk but allows room for character moments that deepen emotional stakes.

What truly elevates this comic book is its ability to balance breathtaking visuals with a mature, layered story. The characters are morally complex, and the narrative hints at dark secrets and hidden agendas lurking beneath the surface. The mix of myth, magic, and political machinations creates a tapestry that feels both timeless and fresh. It’s a story that invites repeated readings, as each page contains subtle nuances that add to the overall richness.

I Give This Book 5 / 5

“Sonora Pass” By Jaime Olmos & Kevin Nichols Review

The protagonists are college friends and former members of JABBERWOCKY, a rock/latin fusion band. After 25 years, the band holds a reunion in Montreal for their friends and fans. Following a wildly successful reunion party, Celia the female singer is found dead. Jonah, the band’s sax player sets out to investigate the cause for Celia’s untimely death. The story involves several flashbacks to the 1970s relating to Celia’s relationships and to her troubled past in revolutionary Central America.

This comic book is an adventurous graphic novel set against the rugged beauty of the Sierra Nevada. With a premise rooted in exploration and personal discovery, the story aims to evoke a sense of wilderness and introspection. However, despite its promising concept and striking artwork, the execution falls flat.

From the outset, this comic book tries to take us as readers into the high-altitude landscape, with detailed and atmospheric illustrations that capture the grandeur of the mountains.

The artwork itself in this comic book is undeniably talented, offering lush vistas and expressive character designs that breathe life into the story’s setting. The visual elements are perhaps the strongest aspect of the book, immersing me personally in the natural beauty of the pass and the wilderness that encircles it.

Unfortunately, the narrative suffers from significant issues that hinder its overall impact. The writing itself in this comic book, while descriptive, is often bogged down by pacing problems and underdeveloped characters. The plot revolves around a protagonist (whose motivations are vague) that embarks on a trek through Sonora Pass, ostensibly to confront personal demons or find meaning. However, the story spends too much time on meandering scenes and exposition, leaving little room for meaningful character development or plot progression.

One of the most glaring shortcomings is the lack of emotional depth. The protagonist’s internal struggle is hinted at but never fully explored, making it difficult for me personally to connect or care about their journey. The dialogue often feels stilted and superficial, further distancing the reader from the characters’ inner lives. As a result, the narrative feels hollow, and the sense of adventure is overshadowed by a lack of engagement.

Additionally, the story’s pacing is inconsistent. Some sections drag on without purpose, while others rush through key moments, leaving important themes and character arcs underdeveloped. This comic book’s attempt to evoke a contemplative mood is undermined by these pacing issues, making the reading experience feel uneven and somewhat frustrating.

Despite these flaws, this comic book does have its moments of visual brilliance. The artwork’s detailed landscapes and dynamic compositions are commendable and often breathtaking. These visuals elevate certain scenes, providing a sense of scale and awe that effectively captures the majesty of the mountains. For art enthusiasts, this aspect alone may justify a glance at the book, though it cannot compensate for the storytelling shortcomings.

I Give This Book 2 / 5

“Free Comic Book Day 2020 (General)” By Jody Houser & Neil Gaiman & P. Craig Russell Review

In Critical Role, the legends of Vox Machina travel far and wide… But which ones are just colorful flights of fancy, and which are actually true? Gather ’round as several of these tall tales are told, each more far-fetched than the last. Writer Jody Houser (Critical Vox Machina Origins II, Stranger Things), artist Hunter Bonyun, and colorist Stephan McGowan bring the Critical Role story to life. Then get an introduction to the world of Neil Gaiman’s Norse Mythology, a new comic series adapted by award-winning comics writer and artist P. Craig Russell (American Gods, Only the End of the World Again) with colors by Lovern Kindzierski (Shame, Necromantic) and letters by Galen Showman (The Graveyard Book, Murder Mysteries).

This comic book offers a fascinating glimpse into the diverse talents of Jody Houser, Neil Gaiman, and P. Craig Russell, all curated to celebrate comics and storytelling. As a collection designed to attract new readers and delight existing fans, it attempts to showcase a variety of styles and narratives. However, while the anthology contains moments of brilliance, overall, it feels somewhat inconsistent.

Jody Houser’s contribution stands out as a well-crafted, engaging story. Known for her skill in character-driven narratives, Houser delivers a piece that’s accessible yet emotionally resonant. Her storytelling is tight, with clear pacing that has kept me personally hooked. Although it doesn’t break new ground, it’s a solid example of her ability to craft compelling stories within the constraints of a short format. Fans of her work will appreciate her contribution, but newcomers might find it a bit familiar, though still enjoyable.

Neil Gaiman’s segment offers a taste of his signature poetic, mythic style. His story leans into the fantastical, blending rich imagery with a touch of whimsy. Gaiman’s lyrical prose elevates the narrative, inviting us as readers into a dreamlike world. However, given the brevity of the story and the abstract nature of his writing, I personally found it at times it somewhat elusive and even lacking in concrete resolution. Still, it captures Gaiman’s essence (mysterious, evocative, and deeply imaginative.) For those familiar with his other works, it’s a pleasant reminder of his unique voice, though it may not fully stand alone as a complete story.

P. Craig Russell’s contribution adds a visual feast to the anthology. Known for his exquisite artwork and adaptations of literary works, Russell’s pages are beautifully rendered, showcasing his mastery of line work and expressive characters. His story, while visually stunning, feels somewhat disconnected from the others, serving more as a showcase of his artistic talent than a narrative-driven piece. It’s a delight for art enthusiasts, but those seeking a cohesive story might find it somewhat superficial.

I Give This Book 3 / 5

“Scott Pilgrim Vol. 2 (of 6): Scott Pilgrim vs. the World – Color Edition Preview (Scott Pilgrim)” By Bryan Lee O’Malley Review

This comic book tries to revisit the vibrant world of Scott Pilgrim in a new colorized format. Unfortunately, this comic book falls short. At the same time this comic book struggles to deliver the charm and depth that made the original series a hit.

This comic book offers a brief look into Scott Pilgrim’s quirky life, focusing on his relationships and the surreal challenges he faces. The premise remains intriguing, capturing a mix of everyday life and fantastical elements. However, the execution in this comic book feels disjointed and rushed, providing little context or development for new readers and not enough fresh content for longtime fans.

The character development in this comic book, a hallmark of the original series, is noticeably lacking in this comic book. Scott Pilgrim, typically a multi-layered character with relatable flaws and endearing qualities, is presented here in a superficial manner. The interactions with other characters lack the emotional depth and witty banter that are central to the series’ appeal. This absence of meaningful character engagement leaves the narrative feeling flat and uninspired.

The dialogues throughout this comic book, comes across as forced in this comic book. The witty, rapid-fire exchanges that define the series feel diluted, missing the mark in capturing the humor and relatability that fans expect. This results in a reading experience that lacks the memorable moments and engaging interactions that the original series is known for.

The pacing of this comic book is another challenge, as it moves quickly through scenes without allowing sufficient time for development or reflection. This rapid progression makes it difficult for me personally to become invested in the story or the characters’ journeys. For those unfamiliar with the series, the lack of context and abrupt transitions may lead to confusion rather than intrigue.

Despite these shortcomings, the premise of this comic book remains promising. The blend of romance, comedy, and surreal action offers a unique narrative that has captivated audiences in the past. However, this comic book fails to capture the essence of what makes Scott Pilgrim a beloved series.

I Give This Book 1 / 5

“RuneScape: Untold Tales of the God Wars #0” By Ryan O’Sullivan & Daniel Bayliss & Laurel Dunee Review

Delve into the iconic God Wars Dungeon and discover the untold stories of a conflict that reshaped the realm of Gielinor. Four armies meet at the Temple of Lost Ancients, bound together in conflict to decide who shall wield the Godsword – the only weapon capable of killing a deity. But on the front lines, an unexpected hero is about to emerge.

This comic book offers an engaging entry into the rich and expansive world of RuneScape. At the same time this comic book successfully combines epic storytelling with dynamic visuals, providing fans and newcomers alike a thrilling glimpse into a world of magic and conflict.

The creators of this comic book creates a narrative that delves into the lore of the God Wars, a pivotal moment in the RuneScape universe. The story immediately captures interest by focusing on the intricate relationships and power struggles among the gods.

The writing itself in this comic book is sharp and immersive, effectively balancing action with deeper thematic undertones. The dialogue is both engaging and informative, giving us as readers a sense of the stakes without overwhelming them with exposition.

The characters which are introduced in this comic book are compelling, each with distinct motivations and personalities that enrich the plot. The creators of this comic book does an excellent job of making these mythic figures relatable, providing enough background to understand their roles in the unfolding drama. This character depth ensures that I personally were invested in their journeys, adding emotional weight to the narrative.

The artwork itself in this comic book is a standout feature of this comic book, because it is bringing the fantastical elements of the story to life with vivid detail and creativity. The illustrations we get in this comic book capture the grandeur of the RuneScape universe, from sprawling landscapes to intense battle scenes. The character designs are particularly noteworthy, reflecting the distinctiveness and power of each god. The dynamic art style enhances the action sequences, infusing them with energy and clarity.

While this comic book excels in many areas, there are moments where the pacing could be tightened. Some scenes transition rapidly, leaving a desire for more exploration and development of specific plot points. However, this is a minor drawback in an otherwise well-executed issue.

This comic book succeeds in expanding the universe’s lore while providing an entertaining and accessible story. It serves as both a rewarding experience for longtime fans and an inviting entry point for newcomers. The blend of mythic storytelling, compelling characters, and striking visuals ensures that this comic book resonates with a wide audience.

I Give This Book 4 / 5

“Unnatural #1” By Mirka Andolfo & Milo Manara Review

Leslie is a simple pig girl. She loves sushi, she’s stuck with a job she hates, and she lives under a brutal totalitarian government—one that punishes transgressors for anything deemed “unnatural.” Leslie dreams of something different for herself. But those dreams are becoming dangerous… This Italian hit series by MIRKA ANDOLFO (Wonder Woman, Harley Quinn, DC Comics Bombshells) will transport you into a colorful but terrible world—full of anthropomorphic creatures, but light on personal freedoms—by way of a breathtaking plot that travels between thriller and fantasy, with a hint of sensuality.

This comic book sets out to explore a provocative world where love and freedom are strictly controlled, yet it stumbles in execution. At the same time this comic book struggles with pacing, character depth, and narrative clarity.

The story in this comic book is set in a dystopian society where personal relationships are dictated by the government. This intriguing setup promises a rich exploration of themes like autonomy, love, and societal control. However, the execution falls short, with a narrative that feels disjointed and lacks cohesion. Critical elements of the world-building are introduced abruptly, which has left me personally without a clear understanding of the societal rules or the stakes involved.

The character development is another area of concern for this comic book in my opinion. The protagonist, Leslie, is presented as a relatable figure trapped in an oppressive system, but her motivations and inner conflicts are not fully explored. The lack of depth makes it challenging for me personally to connect with her journey or invest emotionally in her struggles. Supporting characters are similarly underdeveloped, serving more as plot devices than fully realized individuals.

The dialogues throughout this comic book are often stilted, lacking the emotional resonance necessary to engage me personally. Conversations between characters feel forced and do little to advance the plot or deepen character relationships. This results in a narrative that feels flat, with few memorable moments or engaging interactions.

The artwork itself in this comic book is pretty vibrant and expressive, capturing the aesthetic of the world with style. The illustrations are detailed, with character designs that are both appealing and distinctive. However, despite the visual appeal, the artwork alone cannot compensate for the narrative shortcomings.

The pacing of this comic book is another challenge this comic book has to face, as the story moves quickly through key plot points without allowing sufficient time for development or reflection. This rapid progression makes it difficult for me personally to become invested in the characters’ journeys or the stakes of the narrative. The lack of pacing leaves the story feeling rushed and incomplete.

Despite these shortcomings, the concept behind this comic book holds promise. With a focus on themes of love and control, it has the potential to offer a compelling commentary on societal norms and personal freedoms. Future comic books in this series could benefit from more complex character development, a deeper exploration of themes, and a more cohesive narrative structure.

I Give This Book 1 / 5

“Free Comic Book Day 2021 (All Ages): Avatar: The Last Airbender / The Legend of Korra” By Kiku Hughes & Nadia Shammas & Sam Beck Review

Celebrate the world of the the Four Nations with two all-new stories from Avatar: The Last Airbender and The Legend of Korra! Your favorite characters from both generations of Avatar teams bring you some food for thought—and more than a few laughs along the way!

This comic book offers fans a delightful return to two beloved universes. At the same time this comic book provides a fun, albeit brief, exploration of these rich worlds.

This comic book features two stories, each capturing the essence of their respective series while introducing new adventures. Kiku Hughes handles the “Avatar: The Last Airbender” segment, bringing me personally back to the familiar team of Aang and friends. The narrative, while short, effectively captures the charm and camaraderie that define the original series. Hughes successfully balances humor and heart, providing a snapshot of the characters’ dynamics and the challenges they face.

Nadia Shammas takes on “The Legend of Korra,” offering a story that dives into the complexities and growth of Korra’s world. Shammas weaves elements of action and introspection, giving fans a glimpse into Korra’s ongoing journey. The narrative maintains the spirit of the series, emphasizing themes of resilience and friendship.

The artwork itself in this comic book is the highlight of this comic book, because it is capturing the vibrant aesthetics of both series. The illustrations we get in this comic book are expressive and dynamic, bringing the characters and settings to life with attention to detail. The artwork effectively conveys the action and emotion of each story, enhancing the overall reading experience.

While this comic book succeeds in capturing the essence of the original series, it faces challenges due to the limited space inherent in a Free Comic Book Day edition. The stories, while enjoyable, feel constrained by their brevity, leaving little room for deep exploration or significant character development. For longtime fans, this comic book serves as a pleasant revisit but may not offer substantial new content or revelations.

Despite this, this comic book effectively sparks nostalgia and excitement, reminding us as readers of the enduring appeal of these universes. It’s a testament to the strength of the original series that even brief stories can evoke such fondness and enthusiasm.

I Give This Book 3 / 5

“Oh My, the Horror! #1” By Julio Paz & Brian Judge & Jonathan Chance Review

Oh My, the Horror! The first issue in a new horror anthology series. Collects six spooky and thrilling short stories all in their black and white glory. Get lost in tales of adolescent revenge, a serial murderer on the loose, superheroes expired success, a man’s demonized devotion, and more!

This comic book delivers an exciting mix of humor and horror. At the same time this comic book expertly balances chills and laughs, creating a unique experience that had captivated me personally from start to finish.

The narrative in this comic book weaves together classic horror tropes with a comedic twist, offering a fresh take on the genre. The creators of this comic book creates a story that is both engaging and entertaining, maintaining a brisk pace that has kept me personally hooked. The plot cleverly satirizes familiar horror themes, while still delivering genuine moments of suspense and surprise.

The character development is one of the strengths of this comic book. The protagonists are quirky and memorable, each bringing their own unique perspective to the unfolding chaos. The creators of this comic book does an excellent job of fleshing out these characters, making them relatable and endearing despite the absurdity of their situations. The interactions between the characters are a highlight, filled with witty banter and comedic timing that enhances the overall enjoyment of the story.

Brian Judge’s contribution to the dialogue is noteworthy, capturing the essence of each character and adding layers of humor to the narrative. The exchanges are sharp and well-paced, ensuring that the humor lands effectively without overshadowing the horror elements. This balance between comedy and suspense is critical to this comic book’s success, creating a dynamic that has kept me personally engaged throughout this comic book.

The artwork itself in this comic book is a standout feature of this comic book, because it is bringing the story to life with expressive and dynamic illustrations. The art style web et in this comic book are perfectly complements the tone of the narrative, capturing both the eerie atmosphere and the comedic undertones. The character designs are distinctive and lively, adding to the overall charm of this comic book.

While this comic book excels in many areas, there are moments where the pacing feels slightly rushed, with certain plot points introduced rapidly without full exploration. However, this is a minor drawback in an otherwise well-executed comic book. The foundation laid in this debut promises further exploration and development in future comic book, which has left me personally eager for more.

I Give This Book 4 / 5